The latest battle in the prebiotic soda wars has been waged over a childhood favorite: the Shirley Temple. Both Poppi and Olipop recently launched their own versions of the classic ginger ale, grenadine, and cherry mocktail. But when put to the test, Poppi’s Shirley Temple emerges as the clear winner for those seeking an authentic taste experience.
Зміст
The Shirley Temple Craze: Why Now?
The Shirley Temple has seen a resurgence in popularity, partly fueled by the “mocktail” trend and a desire for nostalgic flavors. The drink’s appeal transcends generations – adults now enjoy “Dirty Shirleys” (with vodka), while kids still love the sweet, bubbly treat. Both Poppi and Olipop capitalized on this craving, adding their prebiotic spin to the iconic beverage.
Poppi’s Nostalgic Formula
Poppi’s Shirley Temple is marketed as a “glow-up” for the classic drink, and it delivers. The flavor profile closely mimics a traditional Shirley Temple, with a vibrant cherry taste balanced by crisp ginger ale undertones. The soda contains just 5 grams of sugar and 3 grams of fiber, making it a lighter alternative to sugary sodas. Taste tests confirm that Poppi’s version nails the nostalgic flavor, making it ideal for those seeking a familiar taste.
Olipop’s Bolder Take
Olipop’s version takes a different approach, aiming for a “bolder, brighter” Shirley Temple experience. While it includes cherry juice, the addition of lime (an ingredient some purists reject) sets it apart. Olipop boasts 6 grams of fiber and 4 grams of sugar, with a focus on digestive health through prebiotics and plant fiber. However, taste tests revealed that some consumers found Olipop’s version too heavily flavored, lacking the classic balance of a traditional Shirley Temple.
The Verdict: Poppi Takes the Crown
In a blind taste test with five friends, preferences were split, but the consensus was clear: Poppi’s Shirley Temple tastes more like the original drink. Those who generally prefer Olipop still found Poppi’s version more authentic. While Olipop is still a refreshing soda, Poppi’s version better captures the nostalgic flavor profile that Shirley Temple lovers crave.
If you’re looking for a Shirley Temple in a can, Poppi wins. It delivers the classic taste with a modern, healthier twist.
Ultimately, both brands offer a solid prebiotic soda option, but for those seeking the true Shirley Temple experience, Poppi’s flavor reigns supreme.
